Categorized | News

Is this the end of Facebook’s media honeymoon?

Posted on 12 November 2007 by Graham Brown

AddThis Feed Button Bookmark and Share

The world of social networking services seems particularly unforgiving. As if floating on the froth of a speculative wave, any sense of downward movement has the bulls running for cover, erasing web 2.0 platitudes from their blog footprint.

But Facebook seems to be a victim of its own success. The darling of web 2.0 media has suddenly findings its good work coming undone by the very people that made it possible - its partners.

2 key factors why the Facebook brand is being dragged through the mill this week

1) Tech journalists have got bored of it but didn’t have a good enough reason to slate it until MS bought in and FB decided to launch “Beacon”

2) Savvy hackers realize that all those years phishing your email details seem Stone Age when consumers are volunteering it to a public platform

3) Invite all your friends to become a Vampire too…

Pundits have been quick to kick the chair out from under the web2.0 cavalcade (before someone else manages to do so first) with influential writers such as Om Malik raising concern over the network’s intentions. It doesn’t help when well read publications such as the Post start running stories entitled “Facebook.com Increasingly Overbearing and Terrible“.

In true groundhog day style, we are currently witnessing a rerun of the late 90s when short lived VC love affair with tech stocks started asking “where’s the money?“. No doubt, investments that needed to be given time suddenly became costs centers when the credit crunch started to affect the liquidity of the capital markets.

You can also sense it as the consumer. When you start to tire of you’re 10th invite to become a Werewolf, Vampire whatever or invited to use an application then forced to invite all your friends before you can use it, you start to mistrust the network. As MySpace demonstrates, once the trust is lost it’s difficult to regain consumer mindshare.

MySpace, without a doubt, is a spent force. In the space of 12 months, its brand equity amongst writers has decreased sharply. No doubt it still carries weight amongst its subscriber base, but it’s more Microsoft than Google - a stable giant rather than a rising star.

So, it’s interesting to see how the media has turned against Facebook in recent weeks… moreso by the timing of their new advertising platform following their “buy in” from Microsoft. Bloggers are one thing, but when trusted brands such as Business Week start doubting your offering, you’re (potential) investors will be perturbed.

Microsoft have enemies. I’m not one of them. Whereas everything Google touches benefits from the Google Juice, Microsoft it appears has the opposite effect.

But the mass media couldn’t really give a hoot about FB or who owns it, let alone what MS is up to. They’ll only jump when you prick them with a sharp stick entitled fear or security… they’ve got a war on terror, immigrants, crime and disease to fight.

That is unless FB itself makes a good read. What if FB was the perfect platform for a 15 year old kid to scam executives… like me? Seems like he’s already up to it, sending the FBI on a wild goose chase.

Which brings us on to Vampires… of the Facebook kind. Now, those apps are fun no doubt, but do I have to receive a flippin’ invite from every single person on Facebook? And if I want to use an app do I have to invite to world before I can actually get anywhere in it? It’s Spam 2.0… and is damaging FB’s trusted brand.

Quote here from Huffington Post shows how consumers are actually being duped by FB app providers. In this instance, a member purchased tickets through Facebook and Fundango only to find his details posted up on the Fundango site.

As someone once said, you only get one chance to sell camel dung in a box. Facebook’s attractive packaging hides a nasty surprise inside.

Tags | , , , ,

More posts like this one:

Leave a Reply

Looking for Youth Marketing Insights and Trends?

Report Contents Download
Mobile Youth Social Media 2008-9
Mobile Youth Advertising 2008-9

Request mobileYouth report ordering information


Mobile Youth Videos

Mobile Youth Video

We provide the youth marketing insights for you by getting out on the street and asking young people about their views and opinions of brands, daily mobile behavior and key business challenges facing youth brands and marketing professionals.

Watch our collection of insights in to youth mobile behavior
Watch extended video from Americas, Europe and Asia (sign up)
mobileYouth's channel on Youtube
Contact us about research for your organization

Research and Statistics

Mobile Youth Report
What are marketing execs saying about the mobileYouth report?

"We use Mobile youth research extensively within International Marketing at T-Mobile" - Tony Kypreos, International Vice President, T-Mobile
"The report gives us some unique insights into youth" - Harry Prabandham, Global Alliances Manager, Motorola Inc.
"We have found the report to be an invaluable source of data and statistics that we have used again and again." - Matt Champion, Brand Advertising Director, Mediacom

Download free mobile youth data from the mobileYouth report (sign up)
Find out more about the mobileYouth report


Mobile Youth Marketing Presentations

Youth Marketing Presentations

We've put together a great collection of engaging youth marketing presentations available for download or viewing online. Edit, share and use as you'd like for your own purposes. Enjoy!

See our collection of recommended youth marketing powerpoints
Download mobileYouth's full presentations on mobile behavior (sign up)
mobileYouth on slideshare
Request mobileYouth to speak at your event

Meet Graham Brown and Josh Dhaliwal

Graham Brown Josh Dhaliwal

Graham Brown and Josh Dhaliwal founded mobileYouth in 2001 to give technology, brands and marketing professionals the tools to better understand young consumers, incorporate youth into their product development, build dialogue, develop trust and establish ethical marketing policies. We currently serve over 300 clients in 60 countries worldwide (names such as Nokia, Apple, Telenor, Vodafone, MTN, MTV, BBC and the UK government). mobileYouth (R) and "Mobile Youth" (R) are registered trademarks of W2F Limited.





Contact us
Find out about the mobileYouth story
add Graham Brown on Facebook
add Josh Dhaliwal on Facebook
Network with more like minded youth marketing professionals
Graham Brown's blog
Graham Brown on Twitter

Mobile Youth Speaking Engagements

Jan 2009
29th Research conference on researching family and youth London
13th Marketing Week: Youth Marketing conference Athens

Oct 2008
30th UK Festival conference London
21st Vodafone brand insight seminar London
20th Wisekids conference Swansea
6th Telenor Djuice seminar Oslo

Sep 2008
22-25th Prepaid Mobile Conference Prague

Aug 2008
13th BBC Breakfast TV

Want mobileYouth to speak and promote your event?

Youth marketing blogs we follow

  • Hard Knox Life
  • YPulse
  • The Idea Cloud
  • Youth Marketing Presentations
  • Mobile Youth Consumers
  • Mobile Youth Survey
  • Youth Marketing Buzz
  • Youth Marketing Blog
  • Youth Mobile Trends
  • Youth Trends Report
  • Derek Baird Barking Robot
  • Beachheads
  • Gen Y Voodoo
  • Youth Marketing Statistics
  • Teen Lab
  • Old Marketing in Jeans
  • Mobilethnography
  • The Learning Question
  • The Brand Builder
  • 3 Billion
  • China Youthology
  • Attention is your biggest cost
  • Communities Dominate Brands
  • Milennial Marketing
  • Talk it Up
  • GoMo News
  • Shaping Youth
  • Culture Lab Creative